April 11, 2003
MLA opposes gay and
lesbian rights in Nunavut
"It's absolutely
unfathomable," Enoki Irqittuq says
SARA
ARNATSIAQ
Amittuq MLA Enoki Irqittuq
says he will oppose the inclusion of equal protection for gays and lesbians
under Nunavut's proposed human rights legislation.
The bill received first
and second reading in the legislature last fall and has been referred to a legislative
assembly standing committee.
"I do want the human
rights act for Nunavut, but to recognize lesbian and gay rights, it's absolutely
unfathomable," Irqittuq said in an interview last month.
"In the South, people
are free to do as they wish; for Inuit, I would outright refuse such a provision
in the human rights act. It's not our lifestyle."
Other MLAs contacted by
Nunatsiaq News did not return phone calls by press-time this week.
But gay and lesbian Inuit
say they should have the same right to protection from discrimination
and abuse as anyone else.
"People in the higher power they don't want to listen. It's like
beating your head against the wall," said Tracy Adams, an Inuk lesbian
originally from Labrador and now living in Ottawa.
"We'll continue fighting.
If they don't want to listen in this day and age, we'll always be fighting."
It doesn't surprise Adams
that anti-gay attitudes exist. She admits that she has not returned to Labrador
in years because she feels her family is ashamed of her.
Adams says that young people
are more understanding and accepting than older people, who tend to be set in
their ways and deep in denial about changes in the Inuit lifestyle.
"I was born this way.
I did not ask to be born this way, but this is who I am. I did not ask to be
abused every day of my life," said an gay Inuk man in Iqaluit who asked
not to be identified.
He uses the example of
left-handers being forced to write with their right hand to describe his situation.
"You're either born
heterosexual, or you're born gay," he said.
If the Nunavut government
were to refuse to acknowledge the small percentage of gays, lesbians and transgendered
people in the territory, he suspects that he would leave and never come back.
"I'd probably be ashamed
to be living in Nunavut as an Inuk. I'm sorry, but I would leave. If these people
don't care and I'm not going to be protected, and be subject to abuse, I might
as well leave."
But Premier Paul Okalik,
the minister of justice, said it would never come to that, because gays and
lesbians are protected by federal law.
"In the proposed bill,
we're recognizing all rights of everybody," Okalik said. "Whether
we put it in the human rights bill or not, it's insignificant. The courts have
determined that it's already in there. So, whether we get a human rights bill
or not, they're there now and they'll continue to be there regardless of what
legislation we put in place."
In addition, he dismissed
the opposition of his colleague. "It's not really an issue, it's just an
issue for people that want to raise a fuss, that just want to score cheap political
points. It's not really an issue for me."
As for some resistance
and denial about the existence of gays and lesbians from the Inuit leadership,
he said: "We were told in the past by our elders, and perhaps that might
not have been the case I can't counter it. I wasn't there. But today,
what we live under, its quite open. We have gays and lesbians who are Inuit
and that is something we have to accept."
|