May 2, 2003
Offensive workbook banned in Nunavut
Publisher pulls remaining
copies of Grade 2 text
PATRICIA D'SOUZA
"Let's
Visit Nunavut" is one of 700 workbooks published by S&S Learning Materials
of Napanee, Ont.
|
The publisher of an elementary school workbook that says Inuit lack the skills
to hold permanent jobs has pulled the book from its line.
S&S Learning Materials of Napanee, Ont., said in a letter to Nunatsiaq
News last Wednesday that the book will not be re-issued in its current form.
But the company made no commitment to issue a notice to teachers across Canada
who have purchased the book, informing them of the situation.
The book, called "Let's Visit Nunavut," was published in 1996. Passages
describe Inuit as dependent on welfare and unable to work.
"Most Inuit do not make a living from full-time jobs that pay money. Usually
there are no jobs available because the people lack the job skills," it
says.
One frightening passage in a section called "The Inuits' Daily Life"
describes Inuit as baby-killers. "Baby girls were more at risk than boys
as a higher value was placed on children who would one day grow up to be hunters.
Families with more girls than boys often gave the girls away or killed them
when they were born in order to maintain the balance," it says.
The book is aimed at children in Grades 2 to 4. One page was photocopied and
distributed to a Grade 3 class at Joamie School in March.
The principals at Joamie and Nakasuk schools, Iqaluit's two elementary schools,
tore out the offensive pages when they became aware of the situation.
The Nunavut department of education has since banned the book's use in Nunavut
schools.
The book was written by Ruth Solski, founder of S&S Learning Materials.
In an interview in mid-April, Lisa Solski, the company's director of marketing
and Ruth's daughter, said the book is a compilation of material from other sources.
"The majority of what I have in that book is what other people had already
written," Lisa said her mother told her.
"The only question I asked is, 'Why weren't we more conscientious about
what sort of material was written?'" said a former employee of S&S
Learning Materials in an interview this week. "They said, 'We rely upon
our authors to give us the right sort of information.' But one of the authors
was the cofounder of the company."
The book's list of resources contains material published in 1979, 1962 and
even 1922.
One resource, "Arctic Dreams and Nightmares" by Alootook Ipellie,
contains erotic and violent imagery.
The letter from S&S Learning Materials says the book will not be re-issued
until a revised edition has been approved by the IDEA.
But Kathy Smith, chair of the IDEA, said this week that the organization hasn't
been asked for its approval, and that teachers, not IDEA members, should vet
the book.
"I don't know why they'd say that they'd have our approval," she
said at the IDEA's April 28 meeting.
|