July 4, 2003
Crown can't raise assault charge
Assault on mother isn't
tied to her subsequent death
ODILE
NELSON
Crown prosecutors will
not raise a charge of simple assault against Lazarusie Qaqutuk to a homicide
charge, because of insufficient evidence.
Qaqutuk was arrested June
13 for assaulting his mother, Lydia Emaruituk. Shortly after the assault, Emaruituk
died.
Christian Leblanc, crown
prosecutor for the case, formally charged Qaqutuk with assault on June 16.
At the time, Leblanc said
he might raise the charge to manslaughter or murder after he received an autopsy
report and further details from a police investigation.
But last week, Leblanc
decided to keep the charge at simple assault, despite the short time between
the two events, because the autopsy report did not link the assault to the subsequent
death.
"It was more what
the evidence wasn't. I would have needed more in order to establish beyond any
reasonable doubt that he caused her death," Leblanc said.
"We know we charged
him with an assault and we know she died. But in order to charge someone with
murder I need to establish that there's a causality link between the two. I
need to establish that with strong evidence and, in light of the information
I received, I concluded with what I had, I could not authorize an additional
charge."
Leblanc would not give
additional details on the police investigation or the autopsy report. He would
also not provide information on Emaruituk's cause of death, because the woman's
health records remain confidential.
A murder charge carries
a mandatory penalty of life imprisonment. If convicted of assault, Qaqutuk faces
a maximum of five years in jail.
Qaqutuk was released, with
certain conditions, on June 23. Leblanc said he believed Qaqutuk had returned
to Puvirnituq.
Qaqutuk's alleged attack
on his mother was the first of two violent incidents that took place in Puvirnituq
over a 24-hour period three weeks ago.
On June 14, Kativik Regional
Police officers arrested Levi Novalinga, 41, for shooting and killing a woman
with a rifle. Novalinga is currently being detained in the South. His bail hearing
is set for Sept 8. in Puvirnituq.
A press release issued
by the KRPF shortly after the incidents said alcohol was involved in both deaths.
|