December 2, 2005
Sanikiluaq residents
put the gears into hydro project
Environmental assessment
left 384 questions unanswered
JOHN
THOMPSON
Sanikiluaq residents are
gearing up for public consultations on a major hydroelectric project in Northern
Quebec, which they fear could have devastating ecological consequences on their
home community.
The multi-billion dollar
power project would divert water from the Eastmain and Rupert rivers, which
empty into James Bay. Sanikiluaq residents are concerned how this might affect
the movements of marine life like whitefish and beluga whales.
In August the joint-review
panel, made up of federal, Quebec and Cree representatives, concluded the environmental
assessment done by the project's proponents had "major omissions"
and asked for 384 supplemental questions to be answered.
By late November Hydro
Quebec supplied that extra information, but Nunavut's working group, which consists
of Nunavut Tungavik Inc., the Qikiqtani Inuit Association, the Nunavut Government
and the Hamlet of Sanikiluaq, feels it's still owed more answers.
"They're playing an
old game, really," said Miriam Fleming, secretary of the Nunavut Hudson
Bay Inter-Agency Working Group, or Nunavuummi Tasiujarjuarmiuguqatigiit Katujiqatigiingit.
In its last report, Hydro
Quebec maintains no substantial ecological impact will be felt beyond the "plume,"
where salt and fresh water mix, she said. That flies against NTK's own assessment,
released in a report this May.
"Research substantiates
there is very much an effect, and just saying categorically there's no effect
beyond the plume is just so backwards, really. It's really hard to understand,"
Fleming said.
NTK plans to submit their
own response later this month. After that, they'll begin gearing up for public
hearings on the project, due to be held at some point in Montreal.
They also could have a
new ally. At NTK's most recent biannual meeting, held in Sanikiluaq last weekend,
a representative from Makivik joined them at the meeting. Fleming said they
were told Nunavik Inuit had their concerns as well, and would also file these
as part of the public process.
That's a change from a
decade ago, when Makivik supported the Great Whale damming project and set themselves
at odds with Sanikiluaq residents.
Like today, residents feared
then the negative effect on water currents, ice and marine life around the Belcher
Islands the hydroelectric project might have. The flooding of forests and land
for hydro-electric projects is also known to release mercury into the environment.
TOP
|