May 3, 2002
Non-Inuttitut speakers
cant run in Makivik elections
Bylaw change passed
with little fanfare at AGM in Tasiujaq
JANE
GEORGE
Makivik Corporation has
decided fluency in Inuttitut is a requirement to run for any elected position
in the birthright organization.
At its recent annual general
meeting in Tasiujaq, Makivik delegates approved a change in qualifications for
any aspiring candidates: a candidate for a board of directors position must
now produce 10 written attestations of their fluency in Inuttitut, while potential
executive members must supply a 13 attestations to their fluency and proficiency
in Inuttitut.
Nominators are called on
to sign these documents, except for nominees running for executive position.
Then, three board members must also provide a written attestation "confirming
this nominee is proficient in Inuktitut."
More than 85 per cent of
Nunaviks population speaks only Inuttitut Nunaviks dialect
of Inuktitut at home. About 30 per cent of Nunavimmiut are unilingual
Inuttitut speakers.
Makivik president Pita
Aatami said the change in Makiviks bylaws shows that Nunavik is serious
about preserving and promoting its language.
"In order keep your
culture, your heritage, you have to do something to protect it and were
doing it," Aatami said.
Aatami defended the new
rule but said it didnt lessen non-Inuttitut speakers rights as beneficiaries:
it just defines who will represent their interests.
"Youre not losing
your rights as a beneficiary, youll still get all the benefits,"
Aatami said. "But if youre serious and you want to work for the benefit
of the Inuit whats their language?"
Aatamis young daughter
Rose, who is growing up in Montreal, doesnt speak much Inuttitut, but
Aatami said he accepts that shell have to learn Inuttitut if she ever
wants to run for an elected Makivik position.
Charlie Arngak, the president
of Avataq, Nunaviks cultural institute, is another staunch defender of
the new bylaw, calling it a "first step" in keeping Inuttitut intact.
Makiviks executives
justified the change, saying beneficiaries raised the issue during their field
trip to communities earlier this year.
The resolution to change
the bylaw, which was passed with little fanfare or discussion on the last day
of Makiviks AGM, came as a surprise to some Inuit beneficiaries who dont
speak Inuttitut.
Raymond Menarik who lives
in the majority-Cree community of Chisasibi, home to about 110 Inuit, is fluent
in English and Cree, but he said only a handful of elders in his community speak
fluent Inuttitut.
Menarik, who hadnt
heard anything about new bylaw until contacted by Nunatsiaq News, said he was
concerned by its implications.
"I was thinking of
running for office," Menarik said.
Parents of children with
a mixed Inuit-Qallunaat background also have varied responses to the bylaw.
"It shouldnt
really matter as long as you can be of service to Inuit," said one woman
who works for an Inuk organization in Montreal.
Three of her children speak
Inuttitut, in addition to English and French, but four others dont.
"We eat Inuit food.
Were all Inuit," she said.
However, another mother,
whose children also speak Inuttitut with different degrees of fluency, felt
strongly that its important to have elected representatives who are able
to speak Inuttitut, particularly since many other Inuit in the circumpolar world
have already lost their language.
"Part of our identity
is related to language," she said. "As a distinct people, we have
to preserve our language."
Many underscored the need
for Inuttitut courses in Nunavik and in Montreal for adults who want to learn
the language .
Peter Bentley, the principal
of Kuujjuaqs Jaanimmarik School, said nearly all students at his school
have come through the Kativik School Boards K-Grade 3 program in Inuttitut,
and, as a result, most have some degree of fluency in Inuttitut, even when one
parent is a non-Inuk.
Bentley suggested Makiviks
new position on Inuttitut could encourage students to learn the language by
putting an added value on its mastery.
"If you really were
a political beast, I assume you would struggle to learn Inuttitut," Bentley
said.
But Harvey Mesher of Kuujjuaq,
who has run twice for the position of vice-president of economic development
at Makivik, said hes frustrated that the bylaw prevents him from running
for any Makivik office in the near future.
"Ive got a lot
to offer," Mesher said. "It took away my opportunity to campaign and
put forth my concerns."
Mesher spent much of his
youth in Labrador. Although he said he has a basic understanding of Inuttitut,
he said he is a long way from being able to demonstrate the fluency that Makivik
now wants.
Mesher said the voters
in Makivik elections should be allowed to decide who they want to represent
them and whether language is the deciding factor, or just one among many issues.
|