May 3, 2002
Non-Inuttitut-speaking
Inuit feel deprived of rights
"I think Makivik
lost its soul when it passed this resolution," says president of Montreal
Inuit Association
JANE
GEORGE
Critics of Makivik Corporations
new bylaw, which requires election candidates to be fluent in Inuttitut, say
it creates two classes of Inuit: those who speak Inuttitut and those who dont,
and that those who dont are being deprived of their rights.
"I think Makivik
lost its soul when it passed this resolution," said Vic Mesher.
Mesher, who works for Makiviks
finance department in Montreal, is also the president and founder of the Montreal
Inuit Association.
Mesher doesnt speak
Inuttitut, but defends his "inuk-ness" against this new bylaw, saying
his lack of fluency in Inuttitut hasnt stopped him from working on behalf
of Inuit who live in Montreal.
Mesher questions Makiviks
right to decide on the qualifications of its Inuk leaders. Hes afraid
the resolution is just the first step in stripping away his status as a full-fledged
beneficiary of the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreement.
As a corporation, Makivik
can theoretically define the qualifications of its directors and executives.
But because Makivik enters
"nation-to-nation" agreements with Quebec, Mesher said it shouldnt
be able to strip away his civic rights as a Canadian by denying him the right
to run for elected office.
"The history of mankind
is wrought with this kind of nonsense," Mesher said.
Mesher wanted to share
his thoughts with delegates at the AGM, but he said he never had a chance to
speak on the resolution before it went to a vote.
"You came and took
away my rights. Dont cut my tongue out for eternity," Mesher said.
Mesher said the people
his organization represents, as well as other non-Inuttitut speakers, never
got a chance to learn why Makivik wanted to make the move.
"Why werent
the people affected consulted? If youre going to steal our rights, at
least tell us. And to this day no one from Makivik Corporation has gone to the
population thats affected by this and told them why its been done.
Why? Why? Whats wrong with us?"
Mesher said the new regulation
also goes against the spirit of the James Bay and Northern Quebec agreement,
whose original beneficiaries including his mother agreed to collectively
pool their money for the good of the entire population.
"No one was questioned
about their language of choice, or did a language test before we put money into
the pot," Mesher said.
Mesher said he is deeply
hurt that the bylaw removing his right to run for elected positions was passed
in his mothers home community, Tasiujaq. He suggested that those affected
by the bylaw should have been offered some time, and a chance to learn Inuttitut.
Mesher said he would like
to see Makivik and the Kativik School Board collaborate on developing language
courses for beneficiaries who dont speak Inuttitut.
He said the $10,000 of
federal money that the Montreal Inuit Association and Chisasibi Inuit have received
for language course development is just a drop in the bucket.
|