June 14, 2002
DFO to study Sylvia Grinnell
char stocks
DFO to study Sylvia
Grinnell char stocks
MIRIAM
HILL
A three-year study of Arctic
char in the Sylvia Grinnell River is set to begin this summer in response to
concerns voiced by Iqaluits Amarok Hunters and Trappers Association.
The association, open to
beneficiaries in the Iqaluit area, voted in December to close the river to boating
and fishing in certain areas for five years.
A similar closure imposed
in the 1980s restricted netting to allow the numbers of Arctic char to rise.
The HTA works in a co-management role with the Department of Fisheries and Oceans,
the Nunavut Wildlife Management Board and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated to
ensure the health of the river.
Dr. Michael Papst, the
DFO section head of science for central and Arctic regions, explained that if
the HTA agrees to the study specifics, it would be run in three phases.
The first will be a community-based
monitoring program, which DFO will lead. It will involve two local monitors
who will visit fishermen using the river this season, questioning them about
their catch and recording other comments they may have on the quality or health
of the fish.
The second part is a biology
study led by Dr. Terry Dick of the University of Manitoba, one of four northern
research chairs recently appointed in Canada.
His project will use the
community monitors, plus a research assistant from Winnipeg to do more intensive
sampling and to study the fish population by doing some test netting, fish sampling
and water sampling.
"Any fisheries study
that solely relies on the catch information is kind of a biased sample because
all you see is what the fishery catches," Papst explained. "You dont
see whats going on in the bigger population."
The third part of the study,
a fish stock assessment, will be run again by DFO. It will take the information
from the three-year research project to the community and conduct a review.
The study does not, however,
rule out interim management measures.
"Were not delaying
the process of developing a management plan for three years," he said.
"Its just the more comprehensive plan will come out when all the
information is ready."
Will the river really
close?
David Ell, president of
the Amarok HTA, said board members have decided to close the river, but will
work with DFO to help them with measuring the fish stocks, population and fish
size.
The HTA approached the
federal department to ask for assistance in the river closure. Karen Ditz, a
fisheries management biologist with DFO, said there is an opportunity for DFO
to impose a closure, but its not a choice they have made yet.
"Our role in this
is wed like to collect some of the biological data first and then if DFO
does institute a closure on top of that, then well have some solid basis
to do that."
Ell said HTA members wants
the river closed to recreational boats too, such as jet boats, but no decision
has been made on kayaks.
Ditz said she was advised
that no legislation applies in Nunavut that would allow the coast guard to restrict
boating in the river.
The HTAs concern
is that people are putting nets across the mouth of the river, too close to
the falls, so that its stopping the char migration, she said. They are
planning to continue net fishing in the bay area where many people have their
camps.
"Certainly anything
that is done in the name of conservation we would support," she said. "They
also want to restrict snagging," which is when fish are caught by a large
hook that is jigged to snag the fish.
Public meeting
Ell said a public meeting
is planned for June 18 at 7 p.m. at the parish hall in Iqaluit to come up with
some rules and bylaws regarding the river, although only HTA members will be
able to vote.
Someone from DFO will also
be hand to present the Sylvia Grinnell Arctic char study proposal.
The Nunavut land claims
agreement says that approval for a river closure must come from the Nunavut
Wildlife Management Board.
"Once we get the bylaws
or hunting rules in place for the river, like no hunting, no fishing in certain
areas, well forward the decision to the NWMB," Ell said.
Ben Kovic, chair of the
NWMB, explained that the decision to close a river involves a process of applications.
The HTA, regional wildlife
organization, and DFO would collaborate on recommendations to go to the NWMB.
The NWMB then decides whether to accept the recommendations it receives, or
modify them, before sending them to the federal fisheries minister for a 60-day
review.
In the case of recreational
boating, there would have to be proof that the habitat was being disturbed,
and that the matter might fall under the jurisdiction of the Nunavut Water Board.
Kovic said whatever decision
the minister makes would be binding on all people, not just HTA members, and
would fall under fisheries regulations, which would be enforced by DFO.
|